The Wisconsin Supreme Court made headlines today for a pair of decisions appointing three-judge panels to hear two redistricting lawsuits. But that’s not all the court did today, and I would argue it’s not even the most important thing it did today. In an oft-neglected corner of the court’s website, the justices quietly posted an order titled In the Matter of Amendments to Wisconsin Supreme Court Internal Operating Procedures. The order eliminates the Supreme Court Administrative Committee formed in 2023 and returns to the chief justice the powers stripped from that position just over two years ago. The order marks a remarkable about-face for a court often beset by charges of partisanship and incivility. Yet this order, and the separate writings accompanying it, offers the first glimmer of hope we have seen in quite some time that civility may be on the rise at the Wisconsin Supreme Court.
Readers will recall that, in August 2023, after Justice Protasiewicz’s election flipped the court from conservative to liberal control, the newly minted majority made a series of immediate changes. Perhaps the most significant was to amend the court’s IOPs to create a Supreme Court Administrative Committee. The committee consisted of the chief justice and two associate justices elected by a majority of the court. The revised IOPs assigned to the Administrative Committee many of the responsibilities historically assigned to the chief justice, dramatically narrowing the chief justice’s control over the administration of the judiciary. During the two years that followed, then-Chief Justice Ziegler refused to acknowledge the Administrative Committee’s legitimacy, arguing it violated Article VII, Section 4(3) of the Wisconsin Constitution, which provides that the “chief justice of the supreme court shall be the administrative head of the judicial system.”
This past May, Justice Ziegler’s term as chief ended. Justice Ann Walsh Bradley was elected to a brief stint as chief ahead of her retirement, and now-Chief Justice Karofsky was elected to serve out the remainder of the two-year term. That raised the question: with liberals now controlling the chief justice’s chair, what would become of the committee created to curtail the chief justice’s power? Today, we received the answer.
In a one-page order supplemented by an appendix, the court announced a series of amendments to the IOPs, eliminating the Administrative Committee and returning the powers assigned to it back to the chief justice. The changes are retroactive to September 16, 2025, when they were internally adopted. Other changes that were initially implemented in 2023 remain in effect with some tweaks, such as those governing the internal timing for separate writings for various motions and petitions.
As a quick aside, the revised IOPs also contain two notable changes to oral argument procedures. First, “The court generally will not question counsel during the first two minutes of an opening argument.” Same goes for a respondent’s argument. And second, “At the end of each principal argument, the chief justice shall afford justices the opportunity to ask additional questions.” I imagine this will play out a little like the U.S. Supreme Court’s relatively recent addition of seriatim questioning at the end of each party’s argument, but we’ll have to wait and see.
While the court’s order amending the IOPs was short and simple, four justices penned separate writings. Justice Ziegler’s opinion “dissenting in part” was the most interesting and is worth a full read. It offers a historical narrative of sorts, recounting the chief justice’s traditional role and its diminished role over the past two years. Despite her term as chief having now expired, Justice Ziegler nevertheless stressed the importance of having a “single administrative authority” to provide a “steady, identifiable, and accountable hand at the helm of the court system.” The flavor of Justice Ziegler’s opinion is captured in its third paragraph:
I began writing this dissent in August 2023, when I was Chief Justice of the Wisconsin Supreme Court. My initial intention was to record my objections to the August 4, 2023 revisions and the additional amendments that followed. As reflected in today’s order, many of the changes to which I objected—particularly those undermining the Chief Justice’s constitutional authority—have since been restored to the pre-August 2023 version of the IOPs. Nevertheless, I include my original objections and commentary for historical preservation. My aim is to provide context for what will be remembered as a profoundly damaging moment in this court’s history.
Justice Hagedorn’s concurrence strikes a similar tone, describing the breakdown in trust created by the 2023 revisions to the IOPs. The opinion also sheds some new light on how the Administrative Committee met its demise. After describing the revised IOPs as an experiment gone poorly, Justice Hagedorn wrote:
Finally, at one of the court’s internal conferences this past June, my colleagues shifted course. One of the four announced she was “withdrawing” her prior votes from the past two years (which, by the way, is not a thing) with the idea that every disputed change was now, all of a sudden, reversed. What changed? Again, it was no mystery. My colleagues wanted to take power away from then-Chief Justice Annette Ziegler. Such a move ensured that my colleagues would run the court through the administrative committee. Following the April 2025 election, they concluded they would have the votes to elect a chief justice of their choosing and have a block of votes to support her, so they no longer needed to seize those powers. This is not a cynical take. It is exactly what happened.
Justice Dallet wrote a three-page concurrence, joined by Chief Justice Karofsky and Justice Protasiewicz, offering a brief defense of the 2023 revisions. She explained that the IOPs were changed “as circumstances required” to prevent “any single justice from impeding the court’s important work.” After the election of a new chief justice, Justice Dallet explained: “Amendments to the IOPs were again proposed ‘as circumstances required.’ Because a majority concluded that the Supreme Court Administrative Committee was no longer necessary, the provisions referencing it were removed.”
All three of these separate writings featured something I haven’t seen in a Wisconsin Supreme Court opinion for a long time. Optimism. And specifically optimism that the court will operate more collegially in the future. Justice Hagedorn’s opinion struck the most hopeful tone:
The Wisconsin Supreme Court was once a hallmark of scholarly rigor and professional distinction. Now, the legal world looks askance at the latest headlines from our court. We are well known—not for our decisions, but for our polarization and inability to work together.
Even so, this court need not remain in the shadows of its past failures. It is never too late to start the repair process. Maybe this year we can try. What if the Wisconsin Supreme Court became a turnaround story known for its professionalism and collegiality? It could happen. But it is possible only if all seven members of the court resolutely commit to rebuilding the trust that has been broken—brick by brick, decision by decision.
Justice Dallet’s opinion highlighted the collegial process by which the new amendments to the IOPs were agreed to:
The process that led to the current amendments to the IOPs is just one example of the progress we have made in building a collegial court. This time, all members of the court participated. As the separate writings indicate, we worked collaboratively and built consensus around many of the changes that were made. I hope we will build on that progress in the future as well, as we continue the conversation over how best to conduct the court’s business.
Meanwhile, Justice Ziegler—perhaps the justice with the most cause to hold a grudge in this instance—offered this reflection:
Yet, renewal is possible. The constitution remains constant, awaiting only our fidelity. The judiciary can restore its integrity by returning to the plain text and meaning of its charter. That means acknowledging past errors, rescinding unlawful acts, and recommitting to the disciplined exercise of constitutional authority. Humility before the law, not dominance within the court, must once again guide our conduct.
. . .
Let this chapter in the court’s history serve as both warning and renewal, a reminder that the constitution is not self-executing; it lives only through the character of those sworn to uphold it. Fidelity to law, not the pursuit of power, defines our legitimacy. And so long as the Wisconsin Supreme Court governs itself by that timeless truth, it will continue to merit the confidence of the people it serves.
Justice Rebecca Bradley was . . . less conciliatory. In a separate dissent, she recounted the majority’s actions of the past two years. She closed with the following: “Rules of judicial administration that may be manipulated at whim, for the purpose of exercising political power, are no rules at all. I do not recognize them as binding. No one else should either.”



Why did the liberal majority of justices even bother creating these curtails on judicial power held by the chief justice if they had no intention of submitting themselves to the same bridle that they tried put in the mouth of the conservative Chief Justice?
And how does this point to a rise in civility? Wouldn't it just point to the opposite?